Skip to content
Widening the Story – Artifact 1

Punitive Labour and Shaming Punishments

Context

Health and Social Welfare Professionals have labelled individuals, who did not display what they deemed productive and efficient behaviours, in dehumanizing ways as “unfit,” “defective,” and “subnormal,” and placed them in institutions. Huronia Regional Centre Staff punished residents for not complying with policies and regimes designed to enforce their behaviour. Staff enforced various punitive, labour intensive, and shaming punishments under the guise of treatment, education, life skills training, and work activities.1(footnote)

It is important to note that institutions such as Huronia were designed to be self-sustaining. At Huronia, children were thus forced to do unpaid labour to reduce the costs of daily operations. Labour included kitchen duties, laundry, cleaning, and sewing.2(footnote) This is an example of how institutions and government administrations exploit those in the custody of total institutions.3(footnote) Slark and Charlebois worked with Sue Hutton to sketch out their memory of scrubbing the floors with a toothbrush, which was one way that labour and training was imposed as a form of punishment. They created a second sketch to show the dehumanizing punishment they experienced, which shows a child forced to lie face down on the ground with their hands behind their back. This is a reference to staff telling children to “dig for worms.”

Pencil drawing of a long hallway with no windows and doors with bars at the end. There is a bar of soap and a toothbrush in the middle of the floor.

Pencil drawing of a room with bars from floor to ceiling. There is a child lying in the middle of the floor wearing colourful clothing. The child’s hands are behind their back. There is a shadowing figure pointing down at the child.

Sketches by Sue Hutton with direction from Marie Slark and Antoinette Charlebois. Toronto, ON, 2021.

Footnotes
  1. Kate Rossiter and Annalise Clarkson, “Opening Ontario’s ‘Saddest Chapter’: A Social History of Huronia Regional Centre,” Canadian Journal of Disability Studies 2, no. 3 (2013): 1–30, (Source).

  2. “Remember Every Name Survivors Group | Huronia Regional Centre History,” accessed December 3, 2021, (Source).

  3. Kate Rossiter and Annalise Clarkson, “Opening Ontario’s ‘Saddest Chapter’: A Social History of Huronia Regional Centre,” Canadian Journal of Disability Studies 2, no. 3 (2013): 1–30, (Source).